It is difficult
to evaluate an online discussion. I'll be looking at quality rather
than quantity. To help me evaluate the online participation I will
look at your entries and categorize the comments according to the
following:
- acknowledgement
of opinion question (thoughtful query)
- compare
(similarity, analogy)
- contrast
(distinction, discriminate)
- evaluation
(substantiated judgment, value)
- idea to
example (deduction, analogy)
- example
to idea (induction, conclusion)
- clarification
(reiterating a point)
- elaboration
(building on a point)
- cause and
effect (inference, consequence)
- off-topic/faulty
reasoning (entry inappropriate)
In addition
I will look for the following:
- The participant
posted messages that:
- furthered
the discussion (volunteers observations or ideas),
- related
to earlier messages and developed that conversation further,
- demonstrated
an understanding of the issues,
- demonstrated
an understanding of the issues and related this to personal
experiences,
- expressed/articulated
his/her thoughts in a concise, clear manner.
- The participant
managed to properly post items.
This assignment
will be marked on a scale of 1-5.
Things for you
to think about:
Self-Assessment
(the scale might go from always to never)
- I read the
postings and mindfully considered the information presented.
- I thoughtfully
reflected on the posting(s) before composing a response.
Reflection
|