J Pharm Pharmaceut Sci (www.cspscanada.org) 9(1):40-49, 2006
Investigation of vitamin and mineral tablets and capsules on the Canadian market
Raimar Löbenberg1,
1Faculty
of Pharmacy,
2Select
Health Centre Ltd.,
Received 28 December 2005, Revised 21 January 2006, Accepted 22 January 2006, Published 10 February 2006
Corresponding
author:
Raimar Löbenberg, PhD, Faculty of Pharmacy
and Pharmaceutical Sciences,
ABSTRACT PURPOSE: The goal of this study was to investigate the
disintegrating properties of tablets and capsules containing minerals and
vitamins commercially available on the Canadian market and to review their
label information. METHODS: The labels were examined for product-related
information. The first disintegration test stage was performed using Simulated
Intestinal Fluid (SIF) pH 6.8 for 20 minutes. Products which did not
disintegrate were further investigated using USP disintegration conditions for
dietary supplements. RESULTS: The provided label information is difficult to understand
and in some cases pseudo-scientific. Thirty out of thirty-nine tablets and six
out of ten capsules had a Drug Identification Number (DIN). Twenty-one of thirty-nine
tablets and four out of the ten capsules did not disintegrate within 20
minutes. Using the USP disintegration conditions for dietary supplements nine tablet products did not fully disintegrate but
all capsules passed the test. None of the three “time-released” products
disintegrated under the applied conditions.
CONCLUSIONS: Industry should
follow already existing label recommendations more closely to allow the
consumers to make an informed decision on their products by providing only
essential information rather than using pseudo-scientific terms. The results of
the disintegration study indicated that disintegration, one of the most basic
quality control parameters, is still a concern for dietary supplements.
Absorption of minerals,
vitamins, drugs or food is a complex process. It can be generalized as passive
absorption via a paracellular pathway, facilitated transport through membranes
via transporters and active energy consuming transport mechanisms (1,
2). In the case of facilitated and active transport, the
uptake mechanism can be specific to individual substances or to substance
classes e.g. ions, amino acids, p
Active ingredients can only be absorbed if they are released into solution from the dosage form. Disintegration is the first step in this process for immediate release dosage forms. The goal of this study was to investigate the disintegrating properties of tablets and capsules containing minerals and vitamins commercially available on the Canadian market and to review their label information.
Products
where purchased from commercial outlets or received from professional centers
and are listed in
Tables 1 and
2.
Table 1.
Tested Mineral and Vitamin Tablets: The front label information is the
information which can be seen together with the product name. DIN is the drug
identification number, Yes or No indicate if the product had a DIN, Stage 1 and
2 refers to the performed disintegration tests, + fully disintegrated, - not
fully disintegrated, +/- not all units disintegrated but test was passed, -
& - controlled release dosage form did not disintegrate within 30 minutes
or 90 minutes. Other label information refers to additional text which was found
on the label to describe the product.
Brand/Product |
Front label information |
Units DIN |
|
Stage 1 |
Directions |
Other label
|
Mel-Vita Melaleuca
Inc. Idaho Falls, ID |
Multivitamin
& Multimineral Supplement |
60 Yes |
14005 |
+ |
For therapeutic
use only |
This unique formulation has 15 vitamins and minerals
with the established Canadian R.D.I. providing the nutrients your body needs
for optimum health |
Cell-Wise Melaleuca Inc. |
Vitamin E, C, Zinc |
60 Yes |
13029 |
- + |
Tablets to be
taken with meals For adults only |
Contains only the
finest-quality ingredients in a balanced formula to complement your
daily fruit vegetable and whole grain in take Proprietary formula excusive to Melaeuca |
Right Choice A.M.
Multi Formula |
Now with
Pycnogenol Dietary
Supplement |
90 No |
402113 |
+ |
Take three
tablets with your morning meal |
Pycnogenol is registered trademark… |
Right Choice Body Wise
International LLC, |
P.M. Multi
Formula Dietary
Supplement |
90 No |
403011 |
- + |
Take three
tablets with your evening meal Dietary Supplement |
Pycnogenol is registered trademark… |
Centrum Whitehall-Robison
Inc. |
Centrum Multi Vitamin Multi Mineral Formula New Formula |
100 Yes |
321461 |
+ |
1 tablet daily |
|
Central-Vite Forte,
Safeway Select |
High potency
multivitamins and minerals forte formula, Essential
vitamins and minerals, now with lutein |
100 Yes |
311230CS6 |
+ |
Take one tablet
daily with a meal or as directed by a physician or healthcare practitioner |
Made to US-Pharmacopeia quality, purity and potency
standards. Laboratory tested to dissolve within 60 minutes |
one tablet daily
Adults Safeway |
24 vitamins and
minerals & beta carotene, |
90 Yes |
3L0580BYP |
+ |
Take one tablet
daily with a meal or as directed by a physician or healthcare practitioner |
Made to US-Pharmacopeia quality, purity and potency
standards Laboratory tested to dissolve within 60 minutes |
One A Day Advance
Adults Bayer Inc. |
24 vitamins and
Minerals, Feel your best, |
90 Yes |
310120A6Q |
+ |
One tablet daily |
Scientifically balanced formula for adults 24 Vitamins and Minerals Advanced formula |
|
Multivitamin and
mineral complex, with extra Bs and lipotropics one per day |
60 No |
66901 |
+ |
1 tablet per
daily, or as directed by professional
|
Certified Guaranteed Excellence |
One Tablet Daily |
|
90 |
65387 |
Yes + |
Take 1 tablet
daily, or as directed by a physician |
|
Basic 3 Atkins Nutritionals Inc. Ronkonkoma, NY |
Atkins Essential
Nutrients Maintains |
90 No |
0497B4 |
- + |
Take three
tablets daily, for adult use only |
Absorb Best TM |
Advanz |
Most advanced
complete daily nutrients from A to Z Holista |
90 Yes |
60040 |
+ |
One Tablet daily
or as recommended by a physician |
|
Usana Health
Science Inc. |
Essentials Multi
Mineral |
84 Yes |
9961 |
+ |
Information not
available |
Laboratory tested for guaranteed quality |
|
With Lutein 30 essential
multivitamins with beta carotene |
365 |
4BA2002 |
Yes - - |
Take one tablet
daily with meal For therapeutic
use only |
Other ingredient: Lutein |
Multiple Vitamins Pharmetics Inc. |
Plus iron, |
100 Yes |
43608A |
+/- |
As vitamin and
iron supplement Take one tablet
with a meal or as directed by a health professional |
|
Ultimate One for
Men Nu Life, |
Multi vitamin and
mineral, Active |
60 |
0045K3 |
Yes - - |
Take 1 caplet
daily, with a meal or as directed by a health practitioner |
In a specially designed base for man |
Ultimate One for
Women |
Multi vitamin and
mineral, active |
60 Yes |
0934A3 |
- + |
Take 1 tablet
with a meal or as directed by a health professional |
In a specially designed base for woman |
Wampole Wampole Brands
Inc. |
Fortified with 31
Vitamins Minerals and Nutrients with Lycopene & Lutien |
180 |
566878 |
No - + |
Take 1 tablet
with a meal or as directed by a health professional |
100 % Natural Source |
Complete Multi-Adult Tabs Wampole |
Complete
Multi-Adult |
100 |
539997 |
Yes + |
One tablet daily
with food or after meal For therapeutic
use only |
Naturally Canadian since 1893 |
Trophic Trophic Canada LTD |
Multiple Vitamins
& Minerals |
90 Yes |
96905B |
- - |
Take 1 tablet
daily or as directed by physician |
Purely, Naturally, All Canadian |
Sisu Only One Sisu Enterprises
Co. Inc. |
One a day multi
vitamin and mineral |
60 Yes |
40089 |
- - |
Take 1 tablet
daily with a meal or as directed by a health professional |
|
Super Multi Plus
Iron Natural Factors |
All you need is
one |
90 Yes |
72290 |
+ |
1 tablet daily or
as directed by a health practitioner |
|
Multidyn Professional
Health Products |
Professional
Health Products |
90 Yes |
F3942 |
+ |
For therapeutic
use only |
|
Super Swiss One
"50" Swiss Herbal
Remedies LTD |
Multi Vitamin
& Mineral With Lutein,
Natural Sources |
60 Yes |
2652 |
- - & - |
Adults take one
caplet daily For therapeutic
use only |
Time-release caplets are designed to gradually
release their contents over a prolonged period of time |
Swiss One
"80" Swiss Herbal Remedies LTD |
Hi Potency
Multivitamin One per day |
60 Yes |
1741 |
- - & - |
Adults take one
caplet daily For therapeutic
use only |
Time-release caplets are designed to gradually
release their contents over a prolonged period of time |
Quest Exta Once A
Day PanGeo Health
Brands Inc. |
Multiple Vitamins
& Minerals |
60 Yes |
517780 |
- + |
One tablet with
morning or noon meal |
Manufactured in |
Multigenics
Without Iron Megagenics Inc. |
Optimum Multiple
Vitamin/Mineral Plan Fast release tablet Dietary
Supplement Metagenics:
Genetic Potential Through Nutrition |
90 No |
93072 |
- |
Servings size 6
tablets with meal |
Multigenics without iron is a unique vitamin and
mineral formula designed for optimal disintegration and digestibility…
Genetic potential through nutrition |
Multigenics Megagenics Inc. |
Optimum Multiple
Vitamin/Mineral Plan Fast release tablet Dietary
Supplement Metagenics: Genetic Potential Through Nutrition |
90 No |
103088 |
- + |
Servings size 6
tablets with meal |
Selected nutrients to support liver and adrenal
function |
Mega Men General Nutrition
|
GNC, Multi
Vitamin & Mineral, Timed Release |
180 Yes |
568152 |
- - & - |
Take two per day
or as directed by your physician For therapeutic
use only |
Timed Release, multivitamins & Minerals |
Centrum Forte |
High potency
Multivitamin Multimineral Formula |
60 Yes |
316153 |
+ |
1 Tablet daily |
Complete from A to Zinc |
Basic Vita-Vim Jamieson
Laboratories, Toronto, ON |
20 Minerals, Vitamins & Nutrients Level 1 potency multivitamin |
90 Yes |
373212 |
+ |
Take one caplet daily with a meal For therapeutic use only |
No sugar, No Salt,
No Starch, No Gluten Guarantee of
Absolute Purity & Full Potency |
Mega Vita Jamieson Laboratories, Toronto, ON |
37 vitamins,
Minerals & Nutrients Level 4 Potency
Multivitamin |
60 Yes |
381678 |
- + |
Take one caplet
daily with a meal For therapeutic
use only |
No sugar, No Salt, No Starch, Gluten free |
Essential Balance Pharmavite Corp. |
Nature Made
Multivitamin & minerals With selenium
& folic acid For adults |
100 Yes |
NK20393 |
- +/- |
As a vitamin and
mineral supplement for adults take one tablet daily with a meal , supplying |
|
Ultra Balance III Douglas Labs |
A Vitamin &
Mineral Supplement |
180 Yes |
427504 |
- +/- |
Take 6 tablets
daily (3 times 2) or as directed by your health care practitioner |
|
Multi Vite 109 Seroyal Int Inc. |
Multiple
Vitamin-Mineral Supplement Genestra Brands |
90 Yes |
754203 |
+ |
For therapeutic use only Take one tablet
two times daily with meals or as recommended by your health care practitioner |
Hypoallergenic product |
Exact Loblaws Inc, |
Multivitamins 8 essential
vitamins for adults no preservatives
added |
250 Yes |
F05301 |
+ |
Take 1 tablet
daily with a meal or as directed by a health
professional For therapeutic
use only |
Trust Exact quality |
Exact |
Vitamins &
Multiminerals |
100 Yes |
F05770 |
+ |
Take 1 tablet
with a meal or as directed by a health practitioner |
|
Multi+ Ehn Inc, |
Complete, high
potency Multi-Vitamin & Bioactive Mineral Formula |
60 DIN pending |
30437 |
- + |
Take two to four
tablets daily
|
Contains no artificial color, flavours sweeteners or
preservatives, corn, diary, egg, whet , soy or animal products |
Omnivite |
With iron dietary
multi vitamin-mineral supplement |
180 No |
0652304 |
+ |
As a dietary
supplement, Adults take 2 tablets 2-3
times per day after meals |
2-4 tablets per day provide optimal Daily
supplementation to a well rounded whole foods diet and proper lifestyle, 6
tablets provide high level supplementation for chronic malnutrition, high
stress or athletes This product is low allergenic |
Table 2. Mineral and Vitamin Capsules: The front label information is the information which
can be seen together with the product name. DIN is the drug identification
number, Yes or No indicate if the product had a DIN, Stage 1 and 2 refers to
the performed disintegration tests: + fully disintegrated, - not fully
disintegrated, +/- not all units disintegrated but test was passed, - & -
controlled release dosage form did not disintegrate within 30 minutes or 90
minutes. Other label information refers to additional text which was found on
the label to describe the product.
Brand/Product Name |
Front label information |
Units DIN Stage 1 Stage 2 |
Directions |
Other label information |
|
Multi-encap |
Thorne Research |
180 Yes 2042040 - + |
For Adult
therapeutic use only |
|
|
Nutri-plex |
Daily
Multi-Vitamin Mineral Formula Hypoallergenic, Iron free Blending
tradition with Science |
180 Yes D0011 - + |
1 capsule 3 times
daily with meal or as recommended by a health care practitioner |
Contents are free
of all artificial ingredients, preservatives, additives and common allergens |
|
Multi IIs |
New size,
smaller, easier to swallow capsules Selekta |
360 Yes 030984 - + |
Vitamin and
mineral supplement for adults Take two capsules
three times daily or as recommended by physician |
This product is
dispensed exclusively by health care professionals |
|
Super Orti Vite |
Vitamin Mineral
Supplement 128 |
120 Yes 0122304 - + |
For therapeutic
use only Take two capsules
two times daily with meals or as recommended by your health care practitioner |
Quality
assurance: Safety-sealed for your protection Hypoallergenic
Product |
|
Ultra Preventive
III Capsules Douglas
Laboratories |
A low
allergenicity dietary supplement |
180 No 0645304 + |
As dietary
supplement, adults take 6 capsules daily or as directed by physician This product is best taken
with meals |
Meets Douglas
Laboratories Spec [#7564] |
|
Vital Life Multivitamin
Complex |
Dietary Supplement |
60 No 7430 + |
As a dietary
supplement; take one capsule daily with food or as directed by a physician |
High
bioavailability, allergen free; All ingredients are the highest quality and
purity available Variation of product color may occur |
|
Mega Multi GNC Pro
Performance Elite series |
Superior
multivitamin & Mineral Formula, rich in antioxidants, fast absorbing
capsules |
180 Yes 577613 + |
Adults take 6
capsules daily, for therapeutic use only |
Vitamin and
mineral supplement and source of ubiquinone |
|
Selekta Multis |
Without copper |
NA NA 030983 + |
Information not
available |
|
|
Ultragenesis |
Without iron or
copper Comprehensive
Multi 180 Vitamin |
180 No 03295 + |
As a dietary
supplement, take 3 capsules two times per day or as directed by your health
chare practitioner |
Comprehensive
multivitamin and mineral formula with phosphorylated forms and ratio balanced
B vitamins |
|
Solaray Spectro Multi-Vita-Min |
Natural beta
carotene complex in a base of Siberian ginseng |
100 Yes 082601 + |
For therapeutic
use only, take 1-2 capsules 2 time daily take with meals or glass of water |
|
The disintegration was determined using a
disintegration tester ED 2L (Electrolab,
The test was performed using Simulated
Intestinal Fluid (SIF) USP 28 pH 6.8 without enzymes and a test time of 20
minutes was applied. Products which did not disintegrate were further
investigated using the conditions outlined in chapter <2040> (11). Briefly: for tablets, water was used as an immersion
fluid, and the test duration was 30 minutes. If capsules were investigated,
0.05 M acetate buffer pH 4.5 was used as immersion fluid, and the test duration
was 45 minutes. Disks were used in these tests. Products which claimed a “time-released”
mechanism were included in the disintegration test. Here it was expected that
the product will not totally disintegrate within the test duration.
Time-release products were then additionally tested for 90 minutes in pH 6.8
without disks.
The acc
Thirty out of thirty-nine investigated tablet products had a
Drug Identification Number (DIN). Six out of ten capsule pr
The disintegration study was performed in two stages. In stage one; we investigated the disintegration of the tablet products at pH 6.8 in simulated intestinal fluid (SIF) without enzyme for 20 minutes. The test was performed without the use of the disks, eighteen out of thirty-six tablet formulations did not disintegrate according to the test criteria. Three “time-release” products which were also tested did not disintegrate. Four out of the ten capsule products did not pass the first disintegration test level. In summary, twenty-five products out of forty-six products which should have disintegrated failed the test.
In stage two of our study, we applied the test conditions according to the USP chapter <2040> for minerals. Here the use of a disk in the observation cylinder is allowed. We only investigated products which had failed test stage one. Seven out of the twenty-one tested products did not fully disintegrate. Four products did not pass the test. All capsule products passed the disintegration test.
Five of seven products which failed complete disintegration recommend
one tablet daily but none of these products claimed any extended release
mechanism. The other two products recommended two and six tablets as daily
doses.
The three controlled release products did not disintegrate in stage two and were further investigated by performing an additional test for 90 minutes in SIF without the use of disks. None of the test units disintegrated within 90 minutes. However, it was clearly visible that surface erosion happened under both test conditions, indicating the presence of a time-release mechanism. Both disintegration conditions eroded the tablet surfaces similarly (visual observation).
All investigated products were combination products containing a
variety of different ingredients. Only in very few cases the
combination/formula could be traced to dietary schedule: “This unique
formulation has 15 vitamins and minerals with the established Canadian R.D.I.
providing the nutrients your body needs for optimum health” However, one has to
know that RDI stands for “Recommended Daily Intake”. In many cases it was rather
difficult to identify or to differentiate the product name from the brand name.
Additional disturbing factors were highlighted “buzz words”, “New Formula”, “Active”.
Such information has more advertisement character and should be avoided on the
front of the label. The font sizes of some labels were rather small due to the
limited space and of the long ingredient lists and other additional information
given. Information on quality standards and standardization were only found on
four products which used recognized USP standards as reference. However, plenty
of self-advertisement and pseudo-standards were found on the product: “Manufactured
in
The USP 28 lists standard test methods for the quality of oral dosage forms. They are divided into different categories: performance test for oral drug products (Pharmaceuticals) (12), and performance test for dietary supplements (13). The different test methods are listed in Table 3.
The characterization and quality control of pharmaceutical dosage forms is much more closely controlled compared to supplements. Drug release or dissolution requirements are core tests for the in vitro evaluation of pharmaceutical products. There are no dissolution requirements specified for most minerals and vitamins. Therefore, disintegration was adapted as an easy and cheap test to have at least one quality control parameter for the dosage form. The chapters <701> (10) and <2040> (11) describe the disintegration of tablets and capsules for pharmaceuticals and dietary supplements respectively. The test apparatus is the same. However, different conditions are applied.
Table 3. Comparison of the performance test scheme recommended
by the USP 28 for pharmaceuticals and dietary supplements. The <number> indicates the USP general chapter.
Pharmaceuticals |
<301>
Acid-Neutralizing capacity |
<701> Disintegration |
<711> Dissolution |
<724> Drug release |
<785> Osmolarity |
<905> Uniformity of
Dosage Forms |
<1087> Intrinsic
Dissolution |
<1088> In vitro and in
vivo Evaluation of Dosage Forms |
<1090> In vivo
Bioequivalence Guidance |
<1216> Tablet
Friability |
|
Dietary Supplements |
<1216> Tablet
Friability |
<2040>Disintegration
and Dissolution of Nutritional Supplements |
<2091>Weight Variation |
<2750>Manufacturing
Practices of Dietary Supplements |
The present study showed that the test duration and presumably the use of disks in the observation cylinder had an important impact on the ability of products to pass the disintegration test. At one test condition eighteen immediate release products failed, at the other only four products failed. The results indicate that disintegration is still a concern for dietary supplements.
However, if a
vitamin or mineral is poorly soluble or its dissolution is slow, then
dissolution and not disintegration is the most critical parameter. Yet, it has
to be pointed out that a product which fails disintegration will presumably
fail dissolution criteria. Furthermore, if a mineral has to be absorbed within
an absorption window and the dosage form does not release its content in a
timely manner, then the therapy might be compromised or fail. An extended
release dosage form on the other hand only releases parts of its total content
at the absorption window like the duodenum and releases most of its dose in the
jejunum, ileum and colon. This might cause a therapeutic failure due to
insufficient absorption of some minerals or vitamins in de
A recent study by
Kamba et al. investigated the mechanical forces applied in the disintegration
apparatus. (14) A tablet by itself hits the screen of the
basket-assembly with a force of 0.19 N. The disk forces on the basket were r
Motility forces
in the human intestine were reported to be up to 1.2 N. (15). The reported motility forces are for healthy humans.
Recent studies by Aytug et al. (16) have shown that gender and menstrual cycles have an influence
on motility pattern. Furthermore there are several diseases which impact
motility like Parkinson’s disease, diabetes mellitus and thyroid diseases. (17) Therefore, many patients which have such diseases and
take mineral supplements might have compromised motility. This might influence
the disintegration of the administered dosage form. The general question which
this study cannot answer is how therapeutically relevant are the r
The new Heath
This study showed that there are products sold on the
Canadian market which use statements on their label which are difficult to
define. However, such terms and statements seem to be used to add
pseudo-scientific and unjustified value to the product; such statements should
be avoided. Only recognized test methods should be used on the labels. Dosage
form and active ingredients need to be matched with their intended therapeutic
use to ensure that the active is released at it site of absorption. Today’s
customers cannot assume that the product they buy will have an acc
(1) Lobenberg R, Amidon GL: Modern
bioavailability, bioequivalence and biopharmaceutics classification system. New scientific approaches to international regulatory standards.
Eur J Pharm Biopharm 50:3-12, 2000
(2) Lobenberg R: Solubility as a Limiting
Factor to Drug Absorption. In Methods
for Assessing Oral Absorption, (Dressman J, Lennernäs H, eds):
Marcel Dekker NY, 2000
(3) Bai JP, Amidon GL: Structural specificity
of mucosal-cell transport and metabolism of peptide drugs: implication for oral
peptide drug delivery. Pharm Res 9:969-78, 1992
(4) Lipka E, Crison J, Amidon
GL: Transmembrane transport of peptide type compounds: Prospects for oral delivery.
J Control Rel 39:121-129, 1996
(5) Bronner F: Mechanisms and functional
aspects of intestinal calcium absorption. Journal of Experimental Zoology Part
a-Comparative Experimental Biology 300A:47-52, 2003
(6) Bouillon R, Van Cromphaut S, Carmeliet G:
Intestinal calcium absorption: Molecular vitamin D mediated mechanisms. J Cell
Biochem 88:332-339, 2003
(7) Conrad ME, Umbreit JN, Moore
EG: Iron absorption and transport. American Journal of the Medical Science
318:213-29, 1999
(8) Basu T, K. ,
Donaldson D: Intestinal absorption in health and disease: micronutrients. Best
Practice & Research in Clinical Gastroenterology 17:957-79, 2003
(9) Grasbeck R: Biochemistry and clinical
chemistry of vitamin B12 transport and the related diseases. Clin Biochem
17:99-107, 1984
(10) United States Pharmacopeia:
Disintegration. Rockville, MD: U.S. Pharmacopeial convention, Inc., 2005
(11) United States Pharmacopeia:
Disintegration and Dissolution of Dietary Supplements. Rockville, MD: U.S.
Pharmacopeial convention, Inc., 2005
(12) United States Pharmacopeia:
Non-Complex Active Drug Substance. Rockville, MD: U.S. Pharmacopeial
convention, Inc., 2005
(13) United States Pharmacopeia:
Dietary Supplement Products. Rockville, MD: U.S. Pharmacopeial convention,
Inc., 2005
(14) Kamba M, Seta Y, Takeda N, et al:
Measurement of agitation force in dissolution test and mechanical destructive
force in disintegration test. Int J Pharm 250:99-109, 2003
(15) Kamba M, Seta Y, Kusai A, et al: Comparison
of the mechanical destructive force in the small intestine of dog and human.
Int J Pharm 237:139-149, 2002
(16) Aytug N, Giral A, Imeryuz N, et al: Gender
influence on jejunal migrating motor complex. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver
Physiol 280:G255-63, 2001
(17) Kuemmerle J: Motility disorders of the small intestine: new insights into old problems. J Clin Gastroenterol 31:276-81, 2000
Published by the Canadian Society for Pharmaceutical Sciences.
Copyright © 1998 by the Canadian Society for Pharmaceutical Sciences.
CSPS Home | JPPS Home | Search | Subscribe to JPPS